Baby Shower Cookie Themes People Always Love (Easy Version)

TL;DR (Too Long; Didn’t Roll)

Pick one theme, then keep it ridiculously simple:

• 3–5 shapes
• 2–3 colors
• 1 “hero cookie” (this is where a cookie stamp shines. Just press the detail in to the dough and you’re suddenly you’re “the cookie person”.

If you want a foolproof starting point, our Baby in Bloom collection was literally built for this exact vibe.

What This Post Is (and Isn’t)

We’re not party planners with clipboards. We’re Cookie Cutter Cabin: we make cookie cutters and stamps, we test things in our kitchen, and we report back with the easiest route to cookies that look intentional (even if you made them during nap time or between errands).

The “Easy Version” Rule (This Is the Whole Strategy)

1 theme + 1 hero cookie + a few supporting shapes

Here’s the cheat code:

• Hero cookie: a plaque, custom name, or cookie stamped design
• Support cookies: 2–4 simple shapes you can repeat

The repetition is what makes it look like a “set.” Not the stress.

If you’re using stamps, this gets even easier because the design is already baked in (literally). Here’s how to use cookie cutters and stamps together if you want the full technique breakdown.

Your Easy Theme Menu: Classic + New + Crowd-Pleasers

1) ABC / Classic Baby Blocks

This one is timeless for a reason: it reads “baby shower” instantly.

Easy set ideas (3–5 shapes):

• ABC block letters + hearts + stars + a simple “BABY” plaque

Make it feel special without doing more:

• Add one custom name plaque (baby’s name, due date, or “oh baby”).
• That one cookie becomes the centerpiece.

Cookie Cutter Cabin pairing:

• Request a Custom Shape for a name plaque or simple “BABY” plaque
• Custom Orders if you want something more specific (fonts, sizes, matching stamp)

2) Baby in Bloom (Our “put this on a tray and you’re done” theme)

If you want sweet, modern, and easy, our Baby in Bloom cookie cutter set is a great pick—florals are forgiving and always feel celebratory.

Easy set ideas (built-in):

• Baby in Bloom collection pieces + a simple filler shape (tiny hearts or dots)

Cookie Cutter Cabin favorites to highlight:

• The Baby in Bloom Collection The Pink Edition
• Mix-and-match pieces like:
  • Onesie Cookie Cutter
  • Baby in Bloom Bottle
  • Baby Stroller Cookie Cutter
  • Baby Rattle Cookie Cutter

Easy decorating idea: Stamp the detail, bake, and just do a simple two-color look (one base color and one accent). The stamp does the heavy lifting.

3) Here Comes the Sun

This theme is popular because it’s bright, happy, and basically impossible to make “not cute.” It shows up on baby-shower theme lists regularly.

Easy set ideas (3–5 shapes):

• Sun, a cloud, with a simple plaque (“hello sunshine” / “here comes the sun”), finish it off with a stroller

Easy decorating idea: Keep the shapes simple and let color do the work Yellow, White with a single accent will really pop.

Cookie Cutter Cabin pairing: If you want a “Here Comes the Sun” plaque or a matching stamp/cutter combo, this is a perfect custom request (and we’ll build it around your party vibe).

4) Baby in a Balloon (aka “Up & Away” vibes)

Balloons and “up & away” themes are a modern classic because they’re gender-neutral, playful, and photo-friendly.

Easy set ideas (3–5 shapes):

• Balloon + cloud + “baby” plaque + tiny stars

How to make it feel extra without extra work: Add a custom name plaque in the same set (“Baby [Name]”). This is where you get your one cookie to give you the “awww” moment.

5) Teddy Bear (Cozy, sweet, never out of style)

Teddy bear baby showers are perennially popular because they’re soft, warm, and easy to theme across décor.

Easy set ideas (3–5 shapes):

• Teddy bear face + bottle + rattle + hearts

6) A Little Cutie (Citrus theme)

Bright, cheerful, and perfect for spring/summer showers—this one stays popular because the colors alone make the set look designed.

Easy set ideas (3–5 shapes):

• Orange slice + leaf + “a little cutie” plaque + tiny hearts

Easy decorating idea: Two colors + white details = done.

The Starter Set (If You Don’t Want a “Theme Theme”)

If you want a set that works for basically any shower:

The Starter Set (3–5 shapes):

• Onesie + bottle + rattle + small hearts/stars + optional name plaque

This is the easiest way to make cookies that feel personal without turning it into a production.

Pick a Baby Shower Cookie Theme in 60 Seconds

FAQs

How many cookie designs do I actually need?

For the easy version: 3–5. Repeating designs makes it look cohesive and saves your sanity.

What’s the easiest way to make them look “fancy”?

Use a stamp for detail and keep the decorating simple. The stamped impression gives you instant texture and guides.

Can I personalize these without learning piping?

Yes. A custom name plaque is the easiest “wow” upgrade. This is especially true for Baby in Bloom, Here Comes the Sun, or Balloon themes.

What if I don’t see my exact theme in the shop?

Send us your theme and we’ll make it happen. We can provide shapes, plaques, stamps, the whole thing.

What dough works best for stamped cookies?

We’ve got you covered: check out our sugar cookie dough recipe that’s specifically designed for clean edges and crisp stamp details.

In the End…

Any of these themes can be adorable. The goal isn’t perfection. This is all about creating something sweet for a day people will remember.

And if you want to make that task easier on yourself, steer towards easy shapes, stamp-friendly designs, or a custom name plaque for the guest of honor.

Looking for more inspiration? Check out the rest of our cookie decorating tips and ideas.

Planning a first birthday next? Check out our guide to first birthday cookie themes — same easy-version approach with “ONE” themes like Wild One and One Happy Camper.